Every spring, a large share of Colorado Springs leases come up for renewal at the same time — and every spring, landlords who waited too long lose good tenants they wanted to keep. A tenant who has already signed a lease across town can't un-sign it. Renewal season rewards the landlords who start early. Here is how we approach renewals with our owners, and how you can do the same with yours.
1. Start 90 days before the lease ends
Ninety days sounds early. It isn't. Your tenant needs time to decide, you need time to react if they say no, and if the home does come back to market, you want it listed while spring demand is building — not after it peaks. Put the date on your calendar the day the lease is signed, not the month it expires.
2. Check the market before you pick a number
A renewal price pulled from thin air goes wrong in both directions: too high, and your tenant starts shopping; too low, and you've left a year of income on the table. Look at what comparable homes in the same neighborhood are actually renting for today — beds, baths, condition, and amenities — then price the renewal against that, not against last year's rent.
3. Run the turnover math before you push for a big increase
This is the calculation many landlords skip. Say a home rents for $1,900 a month. A $75 increase is $900 over the year. Now price the alternative: the tenant leaves, the home sits vacant for just one month ($1,900 gone), plus cleaning, paint, lock changes, and re-leasing costs. Turnover almost always costs more than a modest increase earns. A fair, slightly-under-market renewal that keeps a reliable tenant is usually the most profitable outcome — a tenant who pays on time and takes care of the home is worth real money.
4. Make saying yes easy
Send the renewal offer in writing, early, with the new rent, the new term, and a simple way to sign. Offer a choice: a 12-month term at one price, and — if it suits your plans — a longer term at a slightly better one. Longer leases signed in spring also move future expirations out of the slow winter months, which is when a vacancy hurts most.
5. Give proper written notice of any increase
If the renewal includes a rent increase, put it in writing and give your tenant plenty of lead time — plan on at least 60 days' written notice for most leases, and check your lease terms and current Colorado law so your notice is right. Surprises are what send good tenants shopping. A clear, early, written offer reads as professional; a last-minute increase reads as a reason to leave.
6. If they do leave, you're already ahead
Because you started 90 days out, a 'no' isn't an emergency. You have time to schedule the turn, photograph the home, and start marketing before the current tenant moves out — often lining up the next lease with only days of vacancy instead of weeks.
The bottom line
Keeping a good tenant is almost always cheaper than finding a new one. Start 90 days early, price from the real market, keep increases fair and in writing, and make renewal the easiest decision your tenant makes all year. At Reflection Realty, renewals are built into how we manage every home — tracked months ahead, priced from current market data, and handled in writing. If you'd rather not run renewal season yourself this year, call us at (719) 265-5784. Your Investment, Our Reflection. We manage it like we own it.
